Anthroapologia V

The Republic is slowly unfolding.

I have apparently read the definition of justice.  I had to backtrack and read the section again; it was rather anticlimactic.  The suspense built up over the dozens of previous pages, so that when during a very short dialogue Socrates reveals his definition of justice I almost missed it. 

Still, there was some poetry to its simplicity.

Justice, he says, is symmetry of talent and vocation, a harmony between one’s strengths and one’s work.  Justice is finding and possessing one’s place as a part of society, contributing and taking responsibility for something meaningful to that society.

Can this be so?  And if yes, why is it that in Western culture we deviate so greatly from the Athenian ideal?

First, to back up a bit, the Athenian ideal found expression in a single word, arete, which finds its closest English partner in the word excellence

Second, Socrates and (in his early work) Plato advocated the ideal, but never saw this ideal realized.  They were rational dreamers; they wished and taught, but ultimately the animal nature of human society made its appearance.

Putting this together, understanding and using one’s individual excellence within society serves the individual and the society.  Social awareness is in this context serving in the capacity for which one is best suited by nature, not by birth.   


3 responses

  1. Wow great post!!! Be true to yourself and not what you are born into, by doing that you are in effect serving society in your highest capacity forever evolving in the right direction … or have I lost the plot totally? (this is before morning coffee with cookies… oh dear)

  2. Thanks!

    You’re right on the mark – that’s what I understood this to mean.

    This dovetails rather nicely with the road you are on, too.

    Yum … cookies.

  3. Yeah fits like a glove 🙂 … not easy bringing a smile to my face before my morning coffee but this post definitely did!

    btw I blame you for my consumption of waffle covered in caramel toffee, banana and ice-cream… all that talk I just couldn’t resist 😀

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: